by Freddy Tran Nager, Founder of Atomic Tango + Interracial Relations Insider…
I don’t assign social media textbooks to my students because most are outdated by the time they’re published. Indeed, every time I flip on my computer, Mark Zuckerberg has messed with his giant virtual antfarm.
Plus, real life case studies keep popping up that are so much more relevant and compelling.
This past week — while I was teaching social media at UCLA Extension — something happened on campus that provided great classroom fodder.
I’m talking about Alexandra Wallace, the UCLA student who decided to perpetrate a Don Imus and ridicule an entire ethnic group, including their families, their language, and the tsunami tragedy in Japan. I won’t give her tirade the dignity of reposting it here.
Now Wallace has the Constitution-protected right to say whatever she wanted, since she didn’t advocate violence or defame any particular individual. Indeed, I’ve heard worse at comedy clubs here in the ethnic stew that is L.A.
But I don’t know what narcotic Wallace was on — her own ego, perhaps — that compelled her to flatulate on social media, where the bored inhabitants lie in wait for anything to pounce on, either to celebrate or eviscerate. As reality TV has proven, some people will do anything for their 15 minutes of spotlight, but here on the Interwebs, it can last a lot longer than 15 minutes and that spotlight can turn very hot.
Regardless of what you think of Wallace’s diatribe, it did not serve her personal brand well. She’s already felt compelled to leave UCLA — not an easy school to get into — and she might have to change her name and hair color to shed this baggage, which will live on the Internet forever. Any prospective employer, even one with racist views of his own, might question her judgment. If Wallace were later upset about her job, would she vent another vitriolic video? (Then again, since she’s also a bikini model with show business aspirations, I wouldn’t be surprised if she lands on Fox News.)
Branding lesson: On the Internet, any of us can find a receptive audience for any view, no matter how extreme, ill-informed, or wretched, but we have to consider how the larger community (not just our target markets) will respond.
It’s not just the young-and-the-clueless either: In the past few weeks, both Gilbert Gottfried and an MBA-educated worker on Chrysler’s Twitter account lost their jobs for not looking both ways before crossing social boundaries. AFLAC (for whom Gottfried voiced the famous duck) didn’t want their brand associated with someone laughing at tsunami victims. Chrysler didn’t want their brand associated with an F-bomb user — even if they’re trying to reposition themselves as Detroit tough by hiring Eminem as the new face of their brand. (Has no Chrysler executive ever listened to an Eminem album?)
This put UCLA in a bind. It’s a public university bound to the First Amendment more tightly than a private university would be — and even a private university might have a hard time dealing with this case. Yet the UCLA brand was being dinged by one of its own: Wallace used the school’s name in her rant, and her actions would lead some people (likely USC students and alumni) to poke fun at the UCLA community. (Sadly, it’s also led racists to endorse her on YouTube.)
So UCLA issued a statement condemning the video, but did not take punitive action. Then the entire administration heaved a sigh of relief that could be heard across the city when Wallace decided to pack her bags.
Now here’s my favorite part of the case: the reaction by the Asian-American community.
No, not the ones who responded with threats and rants of their own. While expected, anger just stokes the flames and even rallies support for someone like Wallace.
Rather, I’m loving the reaction of one guy in particular: Jimmy Wong, an actor and musician in L.A. Check out his response below, which includes a dose of Wallace for reference:
Sure, Wong rips Wallace, but does so with upbeat humor and talent. How brilliant to pen a “love song” to someone who’s engendered so much hate.
I’m often asked how to make videos go viral — and this one certainly did, with 1.3 million views in three days, a writeup in the New York Observer, radio play in Seattle, and more. Yes, Wong is amazingly talented, but YouTube hosts a lot of talented people desperately trying to get noticed. (As YouTube claims, 35 hours of video are uploaded to the site every minute. Try getting noticed amidst all that.) In addition to talent, Wong combined several key tactics that work on YouTube.
- Music. And a really catchy tune at that. (You’ll be hearing it in your head all day.)
- Humor. If the Flight of the Conchords ever returns to TV (fingers crossed), Wong should get a featured role.
- Newsworthiness. Tapping into a timely event stirs up a lot of passion.
- Responding to another viral video.
- Integration with his other social media, including Twitter and Facebook.
Then there’s the humanitarian angle. While Wong will no doubt benefit from this exposure, he’s not leveraging it for immediate financial gain. (Note: This is not his first taste of the spotlight — he’s also appeared on the Conan O’Brien show and had other hit videos.) He’s offered this song for sale, and is donating all proceeds to tsunami relief.
So here’s to Jimmy Wong for showing us how social media should be done. (I guess Wallace deserves some credit, too, for offering herself up as the crashtest dummy.) I doubt that Wong thought through all the possible social media tactics and calculated his creative response using spreadsheets — this is just talent doing what talent does. But it’s real life cases like this that teach us more than all the outdated textbooks combined.
Yeah- I really appreciated the response videos that knew how to laugh at the situation. I saw another pretty hilarious one, but this one takes the cake.